Image: Leo Bild/ Flikr

Why is there a debate over the Rosebank oil field?

As government after government comes into power, claiming to champion ‘cleaner energy’ and ‘net-zero by 2050’, why in the year 2026 are we still considering drilling for oil in the North Sea?

The Rosebank oil field, around 80 miles north-west of the Shetland Islands, was originally approved for development and production under the previous Conservative government in September 2023. The Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled that Jackdaw and Rosebank approval was “granted unlawfully, with new ministerial consent required for the projects to proceed.”

“It’s irresponsible and short sighted to be funding new fossil fuels”

– Miatta Fahnbulleh

This has resulted in a split among the incumbent Labour government and cabinet. Miatta Fahnbulleh, the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, who previously stated that “it’s irresponsible and short sighted to be funding new fossil fuels,” maintains that position, leaning towards declining the drilling permission. However, the decision is ultimately up to discussion between three key figures – Andy Burnham, John Healey, and Miatta Fahnbulleh.

There has been significant information and lobbying surrounding the economic benefits that will come with undertaking the drilling in the North Sea. If carried out, the use of the Rosebank oil field could provide £1.4 billion in tax revenues by 2029, increasing to £3.8 billion by 2034. However, due to the nature of the international market, especially surrounding oil in a time of such uncertainty surrounding the wars in Ukraine and Iran, prices cannot be precisely determined in advance of the drilling and selling of this oil.

It is clear that it could provide considerable economic benefits, though whether that outweighs the environmental impact is an entirely different question.

Ani McCarthy, head of politics at Greenpeace UK, stated that “trying to squeeze the last few drops of expensive oil and gas out of the North Sea while the world is reeling from climate impacts is beyond ridiculous.” Andy Burnham has contrasted this, claiming that this drilling would be beneficial “that we look in a responsible way at maximising the existing energy reserves we have in Britain that could help.” In a time of such economic difficulty and uncertainty, cheaper energy bills would be appreciated by the majority of the UK’s population.

Under significant pressure from President Trump to “go full blast” on drilling in the North Sea, Andy Burnham appears to be in agreement with the drilling of the Rosebank oil field, especially considering the economic implications for the United Kingdom. This fails to take into account the longer term climate-centric ramifications that this drilling would take into effect.

It is difficult to see the short-term economic benefit as worth outweighing the climate impacts

It would be an oversimplification to describe the drilling in the Rosebank oil field as either good or bad, but viewing the decision with a long term scope, it is difficult to see the short-term economic benefit as worth outweighing the climate impacts. Furthermore, this drilling, according to research at UCL, would come into direct contradiction with the Paris Agreement – a set of climate-based guidelines which the United Kingdom ratified in 2016.

Not only has it caused uproar within environmental groups, but the Cabinet itself is torn apart over the delicate nature of this decision. Ed Miliband, Foreign Secretary and Former Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, has described any decision for further oil drilling as “climate vandalism.” He is not alone in his criticism of the possibility, with another Labour MP stating that “if Healey pushes through Rosebank, there will be blood.”

It is hard to see a world in which this does not tear Andy Burnham’s cabinet apart, alongside the Labour Party more widely. Climate change is not something we can act flippantly about, as they have described.

However, acknowledging that statement and subsequently considering continued oil drilling in the North Sea can come across as severely contradictory.

While some claim that it is imperative for the United Kingdom to continue drilling as an aid in our transition towards cleaner energy, the International Energy Agency  was keen to quash that idea. They declared that “there is no new oil and gas development on a credible pathway to limiting global temperature rise to 1.5°C.”

At a time of such economic and environmental uncertainty and fear, there are certainly arguments to be made from both sides of the debate surrounding the Rosebank oil field. However, in 2026, as climate change becomes more evident year upon year, it beggars belief that there are no other options for energy security than continued climate destruction.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.