“When your past is destroyed, you have no present”: The vicious cycle of cultural casualties in war
When we think about the damage caused by conflict, we tend to think about the lives lost. But what about the destruction of culture: the silent victim of war? In countries like Palestine, Ukraine, and Iraq, hundreds of treasured historical sites have been damaged and destroyed. As warfare has developed, the level of targeted cultural destruction has increased significantly. This article will explore why this increase has occurred and assess whether the law falls short when it comes to protecting cultural history. Destroying vital cultural landmarks means destroying far more than bricks and stone, it serves to erode or even erase the history and identity of a country, as Palestinian Tareq Abu Dayyeh eloquently stated to the BBC, “When your past is destroyed, you have no present.” With cultural losses leaving such deep scars, what exactly do these countries have left?
In the most up-to-date UNESCO reports, 563 cultural sites have been confirmed as damaged in Ukraine, and 164 in Gaza (around 50% of its heritage sites). Similar decimation can be observed in Iran (more than 100 sites reported as damaged), Iraq and Sudan. This level of cultural destruction is rather unique to modern wars. It’s also unique in its targeted nature. Cultural landmarks are increasingly being destroyed intentionally rather than as collateral damage. Sabine von Schlorlemer (chair of international law, EU law and international relations at the Technical University of Dresden and a former state minister for Saxony in Germany) noted how “deliberate and systemic acts against cultural heritage have spread to a considerable extent.”
To investigate why this increase has occurred, we must first ask: why attack cultural sites? One reason is the rise of ‘war profiteering’, a term used to describe the act of earning an excessive or unethical profit from warfare. In our capitalist, political-economic climate, the unsettling fact that war can be outrageously profitable rings true more than ever. So many modern conflicts have financial motivations, so it is no surprise that the destruction and looting of cultural sites is on the rise. Destroying such sites is also a means of intimidating your opponent. Speaking of the war in Syria, Italy-based academics Paolo Foradoi, Serena Giusti, and Alessandro Lamonica have argued that ISIS/Daesh intentionally used iconoclasm to “assert their absolute domination over the population…including the social and cultural context in which that population lives.” This intent to intimidate is linked to what is most often cited as the motivation behind these contemporary attacks on cultural sites: cultural cleansing.
Russia is erasing the history and memory of Ukrainian and national majorities, and the Indigenous peoples of Ukraine as well. They want to prove that it’s Russian territory and that it’s never been Ukraine
Cultural cleansing is a form of ethnic cleansing. It is the act of intentionally removing or destroying cultural markers with the intent to erase or ‘cleanse’ a country of its culture. The term has come up frequently referring to the ongoing conflicts in Gaza and Ukraine, where Israel and Russia have been accused of engaging in cultural cleansing, with some sources going so far as to declare it a ‘cultural genocide.’ These claims have been supported by respected political sources such as the UN, whose Chair declared that “Israel is carrying out a concerted campaign to obliterate Palestinian life in Gaza.” Theories argue that this rise in the targeting of culture is the result of the increasingly hostile climate of nationalistic politics. Anastasiia Cherednychenko, the chair of the International Council of Museums Ukraine arm, highlighted when speaking to Museums Journal how Russia is motivated by a desire to erase and conquer, “Russia is erasing the history and memory of Ukrainian and national majorities, and the Indigenous peoples of Ukraine as well. They want to prove that it’s Russian territory and that it’s never been Ukraine.”
There are of course laws put in place to protect cultural sites, beginning after World War II, where the first ever international treaty, dedicated to the protection of cultural heritage during war, was signed in The Hague in 1954. A Second Protocol to the Convention was added in 1999 stating that sites protected for their cultural significance cannot not be made a military target or objective unless it cannot be avoided. The International Criminal Court was then established in 2002, with part of its role being to hold people accountable who deliberately attacked sites and items of cultural significance, with the same statute classifying the destruction of cultural heritage as a “war crime.”
With these laws in place, how do countries keep getting away with it? The first issue emerges from the inevitable parameters placed upon the laws, and the subsequent criteria incidents must meet. For an act to be considered, as stated in the International Law Framework, there must be “a closely related nexus between the direction of the attack on cultural heritage and the existing armed conflict.” This may sound logical, but problems arise since the nature of conflict has changed significantly since World War II when this convention was put into place. Today, many conflicts involve non-state actors who therefore have no obligations under such laws. These non-state players, combined with an increase in the targeting of cultural heritage in conflict, leaves the existing international legal framework falling short. This was proven after the illegal destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas by the Taliban in Afghanistan which, as stated in a Harvard International Law Journal, “did not constitute a war crime because it was not done as part of the conflict going on in the country.”
Do we edit the law itself, or its enforcement?
The current state of international law, regarding cultural destruction, is proving ineffective at protecting tangible cultural heritage (landmarks and objects), and – arguably even more so, due to their non-physical nature – intangible cultural heritage (customs, traditions, folklore etc). This is emphasised by the fact that only one case has ever successfully been brought before the International Criminal Court (ICC), the case of Ahmad al-Faqi al-Mahdi. This leaves us with two approaches moving forward: do we edit the law itself, or its enforcement? Some argue that the current law needs reassessing and adapting, while others believe that it is the approach to enforcing the law, as well as our attitudes towards cultural protection, which need to be reassessed. For example, Fahim Abrar Abid argues that “the international community must strengthen its commitment to protecting cultural heritage by enhancing international cooperation, ensuring the political will to enforce ICL, and possibly revisiting the principle of complementarity to allow for more robust international intervention when national jurisdictions fail to act.”
But, as we have proven, cultural heritage is so much more than a collection of old buildings, books, and traditions. History and culture are incredibly significant to a country’s identity and the identity of its people. To strip a country of its cultural heritage is to strip it of its very core, what makes it distinctly itself. In the face of this hopeless prospect, who are the people fighting for culture? There are groups like the Aliph Foundation and Blue Shield International (aka ‘the Red Cross for culture’) set up to protect and repair cultural heritage. There are projects like The Conversation – a partnership working to bring together various data through ground assessments, satellite imagery, archival research and more, in order to “provide an extensive list of heritage sites across the Gaza Strip. This can then form the basis for future management of the historic environment, as well as for any future emergency assessments.” There are even some brave individuals who are willing to risk their lives to protect cultural heritage like Khaled al-Asaad, who was tragically executed by ISIS for his staunch refusal to reveal where artefacts in Palmyra, Syria had been hidden.
What does a country have left after such destruction?
Hanging over all of this is a crucial question: what does a country have left after such destruction? If cultural heritage is lost, what is left? From a practical perspective, there is the possibility to receive funding to put towards heritage protection schemes and rebuilding projects. Take for example Mosul, where a project organised and funded by UNESCO has worked to rebuild and reopen historic sites. This not only restores physical landmarks but also provides jobs and a sense of community – things that serve to strengthen a sense of peace in the region.
But disregarding the possibility of physical restoration, the other crucial aspect that can remain after the destruction of culture is oral history and intangible cultural heritage. This, however, is partially dependent on certain social conditions, which I hope to highlight as this article concludes. Right now, we are in an age where cultural destruction is at an all time high, and that is why now more than ever it is incredibly important to possess a knowledge of one’s culture and history. The more these are passed down through stories and education, the likelihood of culture being able to survive conflict increases, as these intangible forms of culture remain, even when physical sites and documents are lost. This is part of why Israel’s targeted bombing of schools and universities has been viewed as particularly horrific, as they are not only destroying cultural sites, but then stripping Palestinians of the possibility of carrying that knowledge in themselves.
Thus, in the face of rising cultural destruction, it is more important now than ever before to fight for the importance of history, literature, art, and other historical and cultural studies, for they are the best shot countries have at holding on to their culture.
Comments