Image: Nick Youngson / pix4free

Understanding what private credit is

Since the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, private credit has skyrocketed into becoming a major force in global finance, growing into a $2.5 trillion industry as of this year. Before 2008, traditional banks dominated global lending, and regulatory changes followed the Financial Crisis. This meant that established banks faced tighter restrictions on where they could lend money, encouraging medium- and small-sized enterprises that are non-investment grade (having a higher risk of default) to seek alternative sources of funding. Thus, private lenders stepped into the proverbial market gap. Yet, this new lending juggernaut is making regulators tremble with worry over the future of the financial system.   

Private credit is a type of debt in which lenders other than banks, such as asset managers, directly lend capital to borrowers. Lenders and borrowers negotiate a bespoke loan tailored to the borrower’s needs and financial situation, giving borrowers easier and faster access to capital on terms traditional lenders may not offer. This flexibility also applies to lenders, who can negotiate their preferred terms like protective covenants and collateral to avoid a default. These loans are not traded in public markets. However, like traditional bank loans, private credit is usually offered as floating-rate investments above the reference rate, with a floor that protects yield in very low-rate environments. Consequently, this results in higher returns than fixed-rate bond investments.   

Private credit comes in many forms. The most prominent is direct lending, which is when senior credit is provided directly to a firm with enterprise values ranging from $100 million to $2.5 billion. These come in the form of senior loans, or obligations that take priority over all other debts, de-risking lending for investors. There is opportunistic lending, which is when investments are made in response to disturbances in the market or corporate transformations, providing higher returns than in direct lending. There is also asset-based finance, that is, lending supported by collateral such as tangible or financial assets, ranging from infrastructure to royalties.  

Additionally, “junior capital” is a blanket term covering Mezzanine financing and Preferred Equity. Mezzanine financing is a type of subordinated debt (debt that ranks below senior debt in repayment in the event of bankruptcy) that is a hybrid of debt and equity financing, often with conversion rights to shares of equity in the borrowing firm. Preferred Equity is simply a share of equity with contractual priority over ordinary shares in the borrowing firm’s ownership.   

Another type is venture debt, which is offered to start-up firms seeking easy funding. Finally, there is distressed debt, loaned to firms struggling with problems like bankruptcy. The latter form of debt eventually generates profit for the lender once the company’s issues are resolved.  

These strategies are an attractive sell for potential lenders for various reasons. One reason is the higher income potential. Private loans generate higher yields than in investment-grade bond markets due to their floating interest rates that rise during periods of inflation and consequently increase interest rates. Private credit also comes with illiquidity premiums that raise yields by offering higher returns for debt or assets that cannot be easily resold. Going private also comes with diversification benefits, as it allows expanded access to private companies. This also has a low correlation with public markets, unlike other assets like bonds, reducing the lender’s portfolio volatility.  Of course, private financing is attractive to borrowers as well. It allows borrowers to finance growth without surrendering control of equity and is flexible and tailor-made to a firm’s needs.  

At this point, the sector’s opacity makes the risk of default difficult to accurately gauge.

In terms of risks, there are numerous. For one, it is difficult to accurately assess the level of risk as private credit loans are relatively opaque, with less monitoring and fewer standardised reporting regulations. The Bank of England highlights poor data availability around private credit activities in the economy. Thus, it is difficult for the regulator to monitor its links with other sectors of the financial system, like banks, to gauge how quickly a potential financial crisis can spread. However, regulators have still put up warning signs.   

The Bank of England’s 2023 Financial Stability Report identified vulnerabilities within private credit. This came amidst globally increasing interest rates, as higher interest rates made it costlier for businesses to repay their debts and increased the chances of default. Given the Fed’s recent rate hike, this concern is prescient. There are also concerns that as private credit expands to areas of institutional investors like pension funds, there may be liquidity difficulties in times of financial stress. This is especially a concern with pensions that need to be consistently paid over decades, due to the illiquid nature of private debt. This is due to liquidity mismatches: illiquid private credit funds take years to mature, even while investors in pensions can demand returns at will. Finally, there are additional concerns over the interconnectedness of private credit to traditional institutions like banks. The dependence of private credit funds on bank credit lines could transmit financial pressure from distressed private credit investments to banks in times of severe financial stress.  

Of course, there are risks. It is difficult to accurately assess the level of risk as private credit loans are relatively opaque, with less monitoring and fewer standardized reporting regulations. The Bank of England highlights poor data availability around private credit activities in the economy, making it difficult for the regulator to monitor its links with other sectors of the financial system like banks and thus gauge how quickly a potential financial crisis can spread. However, regulators have still put up warning signs. The Bank of England’s 2023 Financial Stability Report identified vulnerabilities within private credit amidst globally increasing interest rates, as higher interest rates make it costlier for businesses to repay their debts and increase the chances of default. Given the Fed’s recent rate hike, this concern is prescient. There are also concerns that as private credit expands to areas of institutional investors like pension funds, there may be liquidity difficulties in times of financial stress, especially with pensions that need to be consistently paid over decades, due to the illiquid nature of private debt. This is due to liquidity mismatches: illiquid private credit funds may take years to mature, even while investors in pensions can demand returns at will. Finally, there are additional concerns over the interconnectedness of private credit to traditional institutions like banks: the dependence of private credit funds on bank credit lines could transmit financial pressure from distressed private credit investments to banks in times of severe financial stress.

With these risks in mind, some recent events have brought back eerie flashbacks to the 2008 Financial crisis

With these risks in mind, some recent events have brought back eerie flashbacks to the 2008 Financial crisis. Multiple high-profile defaults, like the bankruptcy of auto loans company Tricolor and car part producer First Brands, along with concerns about too high valuations and overexposure to a software section rife with fluctuations due to AI, have seen some investors draw uncomfortable historical parallels. Some private credit firms have found themselves exposed: mid-sized Wall Street lender Jeffries reported a $715 million exposure to First Brands, and had billions of dollars of First Brand loans secured with other investors. And it isn’t just bankruptcies that are spooking the market: a large private credit investment company, Blue Owl Capital, was forced to implement a cap on withdrawals after investors launched a run at the company’s finances, trying to withdraw $5.4 billion from two key funds within the firm. This isn’t just a one-off for Blue Owl: its own filings show a large uptick in redemption requests throughout early 2026 as investors requested to withdraw 21.9% of the $20 billion cash reserves of Blue Owl’s Credit Income Corp between just the two months of January and March, along with a whopping 40.7% of its $3 billion-sized tech lending fund. The firm has tried to put on a brave face amidst this crisis, claiming that its portfolio has “remained resilient”, but its stocks remain down 67% from their January 2025 high. These events have had high-profile investors worried: Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorgan Chase, summed up the increasing skepticism about the private credit industry’s resilience, saying: “When you see one cockroach, there are probably more.” 

How likely do these risks make a financial crisis? For now, the danger is modest. Unlike in the lead-up to the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, the US is not in a broad credit boom, and private-sector leverage in US lending markets is declining. The Federal Reserve noted in 2023 that the risk of financial instability is limited: leverage on private credit is already low, as there is limited liquidity transformation as private credit locks up its capital for extended periods (up to five to 10 years). However, the sector remains untested in times of severe crisis, and opinions among the market remain divided as to whether an economic downturn could make private credit the source of a systemic credit event, as its interconnections with other financial sectors like banks can cause systemic risk in the economy. At this point, the sector’s opacity makes the risk of default difficult to accurately gauge.   

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.