Highway sign with Politics
Image: Nick Youngson, Picpedia.org

The case against proportional representation

Andy Burnham’s first party conference as Labour leader saw the Prime Minister unveil a wide array of new policy pledges for the next Labour manifesto. We saw a lot of his greatest hits plucked straight from the Makerfield by-election campaign: rolling back 40 years of neoliberalism, reversing the regional inequality caused by (as he sees it) Margaret Thatcher’s deindustrialisation and the creation of a new NHS-style National Social Care service. There was even a rare nod to the more Westminster establishment wing of his party from the ‘King of the North,’ when he refused to rule out rejoining the European Union. 

These are hugely significant policies which – love them or loathe them – would undeniably have a profound impact on the future of the country. There was also no surprises – the vast majority of these have clearly been long-held principles of Burnham’s. Articulating his desire to see renationalisation in the Makerfield campaign, called for eventually re-joining the EU at last year’s conference and suggested a national social care service as health Secretary as early as 2009. Buried rather deep within the Labour leader’s speech, however was one position you would not have associated with Burnham until very recently: Labour will fight the next election on a commitment to electoral reform, so that, in his words, spoken during his first party conference, “everyone’s vote counts.”

Burnham is correct in his assertion that everyone’s vote does not count, or at the very least does not count equally, under the present system

Burnham is correct in his assertion that everyone’s vote does not count, or at the very least does not count equally, under the present system. The UK’s ‘First Past the Post’ electoral system consistently produces parliamentary majorities that are not reflective of the national popular vote, vastly inflating the seat total of the largest party compared to a ‘fair’ result at the expense of opposition parties. The most recent election results, from 2024, are the most clear example of this. The Labour party won just thirty-three percent of the vote, yet this translated into sixty-three percent of seats (and thus a-hundred percent of the power). Adjusting for turnout, less than one in five eligible voters backed the party which ended up in government, yet the 2024 election still produced a larger majority than any of the previous five. By contrast, Reform UK won fourteen percent of the vote, only to end up with five MPs (zero point seven, seven percent). The fact they came second in no fewer than ninety-eight constituencies is irrelevant under First Past the Post. The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, Greens and SNP also all received a lower share of seats in the House of Commons than their share of the popular vote.

Even worse, Labour received fewer raw votes than in 2019, despite the fact that they were thoroughly decimated under the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn – the worst defeat for Labour in decades. Rather than any great, momentous shift towards Labour simply being exaggerated by First Past the Post, their majority was manufactured by an unprecedented level of vote splitting, as the Conservative’s election-winning 2019 coalition split three ways between the Conservatives, Reform and the Liberal Democrats. The result of this was coined in a Channel 4 interview to be a ‘loveless landslide’, a government elected almost by default, a mistake of the electoral system which gave a sweeping mandate to a government which had comparably little public support. Undoubtedly, this red mirage is part of why support for the Starmer government collapsed so suddenly and spectacularly within weeks of taking office.

Surely then, Burnham is fundamentally correct in his assessment that the electoral system needs to change. Whilst the precise details of his proposal are yet to be revealed, electoral reform would unquestionably produce a ‘fairer result’ than First Past the Post, give millions of previously disenfranchised people a meaningful vote and ensure all voices are given roughly proportionate representation in parliament. What’s not to like?

Well, quite a lot actually. The argument made by supporters of Proportional Representation is typically centered on this position of ‘fairness.’ If you accept, as I do, that electoral reform would create a more level playing field for political parties, how could you possibly oppose it?

The purpose of voting is to elect a government capable of running the country effectively

The answer is rooted in a fundamental misunderstanding of what our electoral system should be. When we vote in national general elections, we are not making relatively insignificant decisions like what takeaway to order in, what film to watch or where we might want to go on holiday next year. No, the purpose of voting is to elect a government capable of running the country effectively. Today, that means difficult decisions. Our economy has hardly been in a rougher spot in peacetime: national debt today totals ninety-four percent of our GDP, with borrowing costs (and the tax burden) higher than ever. The money budgeted for the state pension is projected to run out by 2050. Public trust on immigration is so low that there are masked gangs of thugs blocking boats in Dover and attacking asylum seekers. Our social care system is non-existent. Additionally, one in every eight adults is on an NHS waiting list. Frankly, our country is in a state of crisis. To fix it, we need a government prepared to make the tough and transformative choices to take us forward.

In practice, our system of parliamentary sovereignty means that in order to make these decisions, the government of the day needs to command a majority in the House of Commons; without a majority you cannot pass legislation and without legislation there can be no change. We have seen first hand in this country the gridlock that occurs when no such majority exists. You need only look at the chaos of the Brexit saga following the 2016 EU referendum, in which successive parliaments refused to pass any Brexit deal for over three years, causing two prime ministers to resign, and remarkably seeing a third’s request for a General Election to end the chaos denied for weeks. In the end, the only way out of that political turmoil came in the 2019 General Election, which delivered a landslide victory for Boris Johnson’s Conservatives – on forty-four percent of the vote. What on earth would we have done if, as it would have done under a proportionate system, the 2019 election produced a parliament even more polarised and divided than its predecessor?

The three most significant governments in Britain’s post-war history were Clement Attlee’s Labour government, Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative governments and the New Labour governments of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. Each of these governments delivered (for better or worse) transformational and long-lasting change. Attlee’s government oversaw the creation of our National Health Service, establishing the much needed social safety net, Thatcher oversaw the necessary breaking of the post-war consensus, raising income levels across the country and New Labour helped establish a minimum wage and deliver transformational improvements to the NHS. I’ve admittedly been very selective in all three cases, but it is difficult to argue against the idea that each government delivered transformative and enduring change to this country.

As well as delivering that change, each government had one thing in common: despite only winning a plurality of the vote, they won convincing, landslide victories under First Past the Post. We think of each of these governments, quite rightly, as examples of times when the country voted overwhelmingly for a change in direction, desperately wanting fresh blood in government. Yet under a proportional system, Attlee’s plans for the NHS would have been at the mercy of liberal MPs elected on a manifesto which promised no such system. Margaret Thatcher would have been kept out of power by the centre-left SDP, instead propping up the wildly unpopular Michael Foot despite Labour receiving their lowest share of votes and seats in over half a century. And would the Liberal Democrats, who would eventually go into coalition with the Conservatives in 2010, have thwarted the reforms of Blair and Brown in favour of a Tory party summarily rejected by the electorate? It can’t be ruled out. 

Nobody is disputing Proportional representation is a ‘fairer’ system to minor parties and produces a more diverse parliament that better reflects the views of the whole population, but this is simply not conducive to effective government

Even if each government would still have found itself in power (although in Thatcher’s case that seems improbable), they would likely have had to substantially water down their changes, often much needed changes for the future of the country. First Past the Post does not produce these majorities by accident, it produces them by design. Nobody is disputing Proportional representation is a ‘fairer’ system to minor parties and produces a more diverse parliament that better reflects the views of the whole population, but this is simply not conducive to effective government.

My contention that proportional representation would produce weak governments is not merely theoretical either. Near enough every version of proportional representation under the sun has been tried and tested around the world. In Italy, Georgia Meloni’s government is not even four years old, yet due to the hectic and chaotic nature of the Italian electoral system, it is already the longest serving government since Mussolini. Scotland, which uses the proportionate AMS system, has seen a clear decrease in government effectiveness since devolution in 1997. For example, Scotland has one of the highest drug death rates in Europe, their NHS waiting lists as a proportion of the population dwarf the rest of the UK’s and Scottish students are on average a full year behind their English counterparts in Science and maths – all while the failing SNP government remains propped up by the Greens on nationalist political lines. Perhaps the greatest argument against Proportional representation is Israel, which had five elections in less than four years between 2018-2022 and was on the brink of Civil War prior to Hamas’ attacks on October seventh 2023. 

In this country, it seems unlikely that the results would be much different. With the exception of the Liz Truss government, which failed due to having a human hand grenade as Prime Minister rather than the electoral system, the most deadlocked and inefficient governments have always been those unable to reliably command a majority in the House of Commons. The primary reason for the tribulations and eventual fall of Theresa May was her lack of a parliamentary majority, which left her at the mercy of ten Democratic Unionist MPs from Northern Ireland, of whom few in Britain had ever heard of before the exit poll revealed their 0.9% of the vote would translate to holding the balance of power. The James Callaghan government was largely unable to arrest the slide of the winter of discontent in 1978, in part due to its razor thin majority, which was so unstable it could not even withstand a confidence motion in 1979. Of course, these parliaments were formed under First Past the Post, but crucially they are exceptions. Under a system of proportional representation, this would become the norm.

Another key argument made by supporters of proportional representation is that proportional systems ensure ‘mainstream’ opinions win the day, and more radical parties – some would describe them as extremist – can be shut out. Putting aside the democratic concerns raised by this view, it simply does not stand up to scrutiny. In Germany, the creation of a ‘rainbow’ coalition has done nothing to stem the growth in support of the alt-right AFD party, which now leads national polling by ten points. The situation is even worse in France, a last minute cross-party alliance in the 2024 elections to shut out Marine Le Pen’s National Rally party appeared to backfire spectacularly, with voters rejecting the centre in favour of more radical parties on both sides of the political divide. Le Pen looks almost certain to win next year’s presidential election against the even more extreme left-wing Jean-Luc Melenchon, whose policies include the cancellation of national debt and a 100% income tax rate. 

Turning back to Britain, it is hard to see how electoral reform would silence the voices of Britain’s perceived ‘radical’ parties. At this point, the differences between the Conservatives and Labour are so pronounced that the idea of a ‘uniparty’ alliance is unrealistic. As such, one is bound to conclude that British politics would divide into two camps – a left bloc and a right bloc – should electoral reform be passed (for a comparable example of this, see Sweden).

Inevitably, this would see an alliance between the Conservatives and Reform UK on the right. That would near guarantee the Conservative party is never to return to its one-nation, more moderate wing, and push the right bloc further away from the ‘mainstream’ opinions that proportional representation supposedly safeguards. Far from bringing down the Farage star, proportional representation would see his brand of politics given a permanent place in the political mainstream. Worse still, current polling numbers indicate any shot at a right-wing government under proportional representation might necessitate the inclusion of Restore Britain, an organisation who undeniably rely on racist rhetoric at least partially, and whose leader has refused to condemn far-right agitators like Tommy Robinson and Danny Tommo. 

Rather than side-lining more radical views, a proportional voting system is far more likely to give those who hold them a say in government

The precarious inclusion of dangerous parties would not be limited to the right either. Whilst one would like to think the most extreme parties, such as the Workers Party of Britain, would not be included, it is very possible a left-wing alliance would be propped up on separatist votes from the SNP and Plaid Cymru, inevitably resulting in referendums every other Tuesday on the future of the union. More pertinently, a left-wing government may well prove to be reliant (and on current polls, would rely) on the support of the Green Party, who voted against a motion to protect Jewish members from expulsion from the party for attending synagogue at their conference last week and whose deputy leader, Mothin Ali, has described Hamas’ evil actions on October seventh on his social media as a “fight back.” Rather than side-lining more radical views, a proportional voting system is far more likely to give those who hold them a say in government.

So yes, First Past the Post is a remarkably unfair voting system – no fair-minded person could deny that. But the 67% of British voters who voted in favour of its retention in the 2011 AV referendum were ultimately right to do so. 

Yes, First Past the Post disadvantages third parties – but they still have a role to play. In 2015, UKIP had just one MP elected – but the level of their support pushed David Cameron to hold the EU referendum the following year, ultimately leading to Brexit and the achievement of UKIP’s singular political goal. During his ill-fated by-election campaign in Holborn and St Pancras, Green Leader Zack Polanski argued that it was a success of his leadership that Labour had moved more to the left on issues like Gaza, taking credit for the government’s decision to ban the importation of goods from illegal settlements. Green party activist Russell Warfield has taken it a step further, arguing on the PoliticsJoe podcast “without the success that the Green party has had over the past year, you don’t get Prime Minister Burnham”. Furthermore, the success of Reform UK does demonstrate that – hard as it may be to gatecrash the political establishment – it is possible to do so. 

To scrap First Past the Post would mean losing the best tool we’ve got to have governments that can actually deliver meaningful change

Yes, electoral reform is at face value a noble cause which would deliver a more representative parliament. But to scrap First Past the Post would mean losing the best tool we’ve got to have governments that can actually deliver meaningful change. Yes, its ‘winner’s bonus’ arguably delivers undemocratic results, but proportional representation would give fringe parties, often those with views strongly opposed by most of the electorate, the power to act as kingmakers and exercise undue influence within government. There is no perfect voting system, but when it comes to electoral reform the choice is stark. Is the imperfection of rule by the plurality so great that we must turn to rule by the minority instead?

If you want a divided parliament largely reflective of the national picture, then you should support proportional representation. But if you want a government with the majority it requires to pass much-needed, meaningful legislation, if you oppose fringe and extremist parties being given the power to act as kingmakers and hold the country to ransom and if you want parties to spend more time focused on working for you than doing imperfect deals with one another, then you should embrace the practical imperfection of First Past the Post. To borrow from Winston Churchill, ‘First past the Post is the worst form of electoral system – apart from all the others’.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.