Sorry, I didn’t intend to be ‘skinny’: the complaints of a foodie
Self-confessed food lover Ann Yip tells us why being called skinny is not always a compliment
I am not really sure how many girls out there would share my opinion. As a petite girl, I die a little inside when someone compliments me for being ‘slim’ or ‘in shape’ and that I mustn’t eat a lot, or that I must have a very healthy diet. My response is often: “but I like fried chicken!”
So to prove that not all ‘skinny’ people go on diets or eat ‘right’ (whatever that means), I decided to undertake a project: to count my calories for five days. I have actually undertaken this experiment as accurately and honestly as possible and have not been purposely stuffing myself. The results are summed up in the chart below.
For further reference, my body mass index (BMI) ranges from 21 to 22, the middle ranges of ‘healthy weight’
As seen above, I am far from being the ‘skinny chick’ who eats under the 2000 calories every day, the recommended daily intake for women. Instead, I eat an average (or mean) of 2240 calories every day, a 12 percent surplus for women. In fact, I don’t actually care how many calories I eat every day, which explains the weird fluctuation of numbers.
Sadly, in this research, I have also had to reveal the kinds of food I ate. Yes, I actually eat processed sausages, instant noodles, chips, chicken nuggets, spicy food, instant coffee and instant milk tea on a day to day basis. I am not really sure if I can still qualify as a ‘healthy eater’.
One of the biggest reasons why I get a bit glum when being complimented as ‘skinny’ is that, for me, far from the idea of looking like a model, being skinny implies powerlessness or an empty stomach. Having grown up as an ambitious athlete, this is of course not an ideal way to be viewed by anybody, especially when I do eat.
Secondly, I am not a preacher of healthy eating. So when my ‘slimness’ becomes an emblem of healthy eating, I feel like I, as a person, am being misjudged. I am not saying that healthy eating is bad, it’s just not me. I identify myself as an absolute food lover; I love any kind of food bursting with flavour, spices, salt and all the ‘horrible’ kinds of seasoning: street food, fast food, pub food, restaurant food, you name it. Of course, I would rather we talk about the importance of healthy eating another day – or not at all.
I am not trying to be vain and say that I can still be ‘in shape’ (whatever that means) and eat whatever I want. In fact, I envy larger girls, which is a feeling I don’t get with girls skinnier than me, even if I do appreciate that they look great too. On the other hand, I see myself as a heftier version of a petite despite what other people say.
From my exhaustive calorie counting attempt, I wanted to prove that not all ‘skinny’ people eat less or eat healthily. But perhaps more can be deduced from this – that sometimes we are not always what we eat. So large girls, stop thinking that you need to eat less to achieve a ‘slim’ physique and skinny people, stop trying to make yourself fat to look ‘normal’. Sometimes, our physiques are what they are and we might not be able to change them as radically as we like.
Comments (4)
I’m glad this is being talked about. In this culture we’re very quick to associate weight with health and skinniness with beauty, to the exclusion of all other factors, and that’s just not how it works.
Shouldn’t someone who has been an “ambitious” athlete since childhood have (and understand the importance of) a more healthy, balanced diet, instead of eating foods such as instant noodles and sausages, and having only one meal for the entire day in Day 2? This article seems more like a humble brag more than anything…
Hannah, an ‘ambitious athlete’ doesn’t always have to conform to stereotypes, nor does it mean that they have to eat perfectly all the time. Even athletes have personalities, habits, things they like/dislike, they’re not the perfectly disciplined robotic beings you envision them to be. Besides, there is much more to being a sportsman than eating right; there’s fitness, agility, technique, mindset, teamwork, strength and so on. Just because you don’t happen to eat ‘right’ does not automatically exclude you from being a sportsperson.
As for Day 2, I was actually so busy coding a web app the whole day that I forgot to eat! So that was a one-off…
Also, yes I am ‘bragging’, I am ‘bragging’ about the fact that I love food and flavour, and that I don’t care what other people think of the junk I eat. But if you think that I’m ‘humbly bragging’ about the fact that people view me as ‘skinny’, I would find it quite offensive. Being deemed as ‘skinny’ is something that I still have difficulty coming to terms with, and I don’t think a lot of people really understand my struggle. I wish other people would understand that some people do have different ideas of the ‘ideal’ body type.
We only know from this article what energy is being taken in, without any idea of what’s being expended; I’d infer that the author enjoys exercise, given the reference to athleticism. All ‘diets’, after all, can be summarised as eat less / move more. So if she’s running several km / day whilst eating junk food, she’s still going to be in rather trimmer shape than a lower calorie intake couch potato.
(And actually, the energetic types I know are often prone to eating rubbish precisely BECA– USE they get to burn it all off. Jealous, moi?)